Home » Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Take a Stroll Down Memory Lane with all the Old Fashioned & Retro Candy you remember...and some you forgot!

Filter products
Clear all

1834 Products

  • Baby Bottle Pop 24g

    Baby Bottle Pop - 24g

    $3.49
  • Peeps Gingerbread Marshmallow Men - 6ct

    Peeps Gingerbread Marshmallow Men - 6ct

    $4.99
  • Cella's Cherry Milk Chocolate Gift Box - 141g

    Cella's Cherry Milk Chocolate Gift Box - 141g

    $6.49
  • Cup-O-Gold - 1.25oz

    Cup-O-Gold - 1.25oz

    $3.49
  • Cherry Mash - 2.05oz

    Cherry Mash - 2.05oz

    $2.99
  • Nerds Frosty Holiday Clusters - 3oz

    Nerds Frosty Holiday Clusters - 3oz

    $5.99
  • Slaps Tropical Mix 3.53oz

    Slaps Lollipops Tropical Mix - 3.53oz

    $4.99
  • Moon Pie Pumpkin Spice - 2.75oz

    Moon Pie Pumpkin Spice - 2.75oz

    $1.79
  • Salt Water Taffy Pineapple 2.5lb

    Salt Water Taffy - Pineapple - 2.5lb

    $29.99
  • Salt Water Taffy Blueberry Muffin - 2.5lb

    Salt Water Taffy Blueberry Muffin - 2.5lb

    $29.99
  • Salt Water Taffy Raspberry Lemonade - 2.5lb

    Salt Water Taffy Raspberry Lemonade - 2.5lb

    $29.99
  • Salt Water Taffy - Banana Cream Pie - 2.5lb

    Salt Water Taffy - Banana Cream Pie - 2.5lb

    $29.99
  • Salt Water Taffy Strawberry Banana 2.5lb

    Salt Water Taffy Strawberry Banana - 2.5lb

    $29.99
  • Salt Water Taffy Apple Pie 2.5lb

    Salt Water Taffy Apple Pie - 2.5lb

    $29.99
  • Salt Water Taffy Chocolate Mint 2.5lb

    Salt Water Taffy Chocolate Mint - 2.5lb

    $29.99
  • Salt Water Taffy Tropical Punch 2.5lb

    Salt Water Taffy Tropical Punch - 2.5lb

    $29.99
  • Crack Ups - 100ct

    Dubble Bubble Ghoul's Gum - 175ct

    $26.99
  • Goetze Oreo Caramel Creams 1.9oz

    Goetze Oreo Caramel Creams - 1.9oz

    $2.49
  • Cow Tales Oreo 1oz

    Cow Tales Oreo - 1oz

    $0.99
  • Monster Mash Cereal 16oz

    Halloween Monster Mash Cereal - 16oz

    $11.99
  • Halloween Decorated Butter Cookies

    Halloween Decorated Butter Cookies

    $4.49
  • Vidal Gummi Eyeballs - 4.4lbs

    Vidal Gummi Eyeballs - 4.4lbs

    $34.99
  • Doritos Twisted Lime 18.8oz

    Doritos Twisted Lime - 18.8oz

    $13.99
  • Annabelle Giant Chewy Assortment 35oz

    Halloween Annabelle Giant Chewy Assortment - 35oz

    $33.99