Home » Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Take a Stroll Down Memory Lane with all the Old Fashioned & Retro Candy you remember...and some you forgot!

Filter products
Clear all

1833 Products

  • Pez Collections Finding Dory Gift Set Pez 0.9kg - 2000s Era_2000s Novelty pez Toy

    Pez Collections Finding Dory Gift Set

    $25.00
  • Choward's Violet Mints 24g

    Choward's Violet

    $1.99
  • Big League Chew Curveball Cotton Candy

    Big League Chew Curveball Cotton Candy

    $3.59
  • Oreo Birthday Cake Vanilla - Cookies

    Oreo Birthday Cake Vanilla

    $8.00
  • Kool-Aid Black Cherry Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Black Cherry Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Strawberry Kiwi Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Strawberry Kiwi Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Lemonade Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Lemonade Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Grape Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Grape Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Orange Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Orange Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Butterfinger | Peanut Butter Chocolate Bars | Candy Funhouse

    Butterfinger - 1.9oz

    $3.49
  • Kool-Aid Blue Raspberry Lemonade Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Blue Raspberry Lemonade Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Tropical Punch Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Tropical Punch Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Pink Lemonade Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Pink Lemonade Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Strawberry Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Strawberry Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Milky Way Simply Caramel Mars 60g - 2000s American Bar Caramel Chocolate

    Milky Way Simply Caramel

    $2.39
  • Milky Way Midnight Dark

    Milky Way Midnight Dark - 2.83oz

    $5.99
  • Nestle Kit Kat White Bar 41g

    Nestle Kit Kat White Bar - 41g

    $2.99
  • Milky Way Bar - 1.84oz

    Milky Way Bar - 1.84oz

    $3.99
  • Swedish Fish Bulk Candy 3.5 lbs

    Swedish Fish Bulk Candy-3.5 lbs

    $29.99
  • Charms Fluffy Stuff Cotton Candy Bag 2.5 oz.

    Charms Fluffy Stuff Cotton Candy Bag - 2.5oz

    $3.99
  • Oreo Birthday Cake Family Size - 17oz

    Oreo Birthday Cake Family Size - 17oz

    $13.99
  • Kool-Aid Cherry Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Cherry Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Oreo Peanut Butter Family Size - 17oz

    Oreo Peanut Butter Family Size - 17oz

    $11.99
  • Oreo Cinnamon Bun - Cookies

    Oreo Cinnamon Bun - 261g

    $8.99