Home » Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Take a Stroll Down Memory Lane with all the Old Fashioned & Retro Candy you remember...and some you forgot!

Filter products
Clear all

1833 Products

  • Christmas Nerds Candy Frosty Theater Box - 5oz - Nerds Candy Frosty Theater Box - Winter Wonderland Sweets - Holiday Candy Mix - Festive Movie Night Snacks - Christmas Candy Treats - Snowman-Approved Candy - Sweet and Tangy Nerds - Unique Winter Candy - Nerds Candies - Nerds Candy

    Nerds Candy Frosty Theater Box - 5oz

    $4.49
  • Nerds Rope Christmas Candy - .92oz - Nerds Candy - Nerds Ropes - Holiday Candy - Wonka Candy - Chewy Candy

    Nerds Rope Christmas Candy - .92oz

    $3.49
  • Kool-Aid Mango Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Mango Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Mandarina-Tangerine Drink Mix Packet Kraft Foods Group Inc. 10g - 1920s 2000s Drink Mix Era_1920s Era_2000s

    Kool-Aid Mandarina-Tangerine Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Green Apple Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Green Apple Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Sharkleberry Fin Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Sharkleberry Fin Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Reeses Sticks 42g

    Reese's Sticks - 42g

    $2.49
  • Star Wars Rouge One PEZ Collectors Tin Pez 4kg - 2000s Christmas Gift Ideas Era_2000s Novelty pez

    Pez Star Wars Rogue One PEZ Collectors Tin

    $45.00
  • Kraft Caramels Original Kraft Fiids Group Inc. 350g - 1930s Canadian Canadian Candy Caramel Era_1930s

    Kraft Caramels Original

    $5.00
  • Haribo Starmix - 5oz

    Haribo Starmix - 5oz

    $3.99
  • Haribo Tangfastics UK

    Haribo Tangfastics UK

    $4.49
  • Barrett Black Jack Stick

    Barrett Black Jack Stick

    $60.00
  • Big League Bubble Gum Balls-Outta Here Original Ford Gum & Machine Company 50g - 2000s Big League Chew Bubble Gum Era_2000s Gum

    Big League Gum Balls Tube - Outta Here Original

    $1.99
  • Haribo Rotella - 120g

    Haribo Rotella - 120g

    $5.99
  • efrutti Gummi Pizza Candy 15g

    efrutti Gummi Pizza Candy - 48ct

    $37.49
  • Lucky Elephant Pink Candy Popcorn

    Lucky Elephant Pink Candy Popcorn

    $3.99
  • M&Ms Minis Mars 50g - 2000s American Chocolate Era_2000s m&ms

    M&M's Minis Box (24ct)

    $36.00
  • Reeses Half Pound Cup Hersheys 300g - 2000s American Bar Chocolate Era_2000s

    Christmas Reese's Half Pound Cup

    $8.00
  • Reese's Stuffed with Pieces Big Cup King Size 79g

    Reese's Stuffed with Pieces Big Cup King Size - 2.8oz

    $6.49
  • Reese's Stuffed with Pieces Candy 42g

    Reese's Stuffed with Pieces Candy - 42g

    $2.49
  • AirHeads Candy Watermelon Taffy - 15.6g

    Airheads Candy - Watermelon Taffy Bar 15.6g

    $0.69
  • AirHeads Candy Strawberry Taffy -15.6g

    Airheads Candy - Strawberry Taffy 15.6g

    $0.69
  • AirHeads Candy Taffy Bars Blue Raspberry - 15.6g

    AirHeads Candy - Blue Raspberry Taffy Bars 15.6g

    $0.69
  • Airheads Candy - Orange Taffy Bars - 15.6g

    Airheads Candy - Orange Taffy Bars 15.6g

    $0.69