Home » Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Take a Stroll Down Memory Lane with all the Old Fashioned & Retro Candy you remember...and some you forgot!

Filter products
Clear all

1833 Products

  • Oreo Mega Stuf Cookie - Oreo Mega Stuf - Cookies

    Oreo Mega Stuf Cookie

    $8.00
  • Boyer Butterscotch Smoothie Peanut Butter Cups

    Boyer Butterscotch Smoothie Peanut Butter Cups

    $3.49
  • Boyer Mallo Cup Dark Chocolate Boyer 0.04kg - 1930s American American Bar Bar Chocolate

    Boyer Mallo Cup Dark Chocolate

    $2.00
  • Mike and Ike Root Beer Float Theatre Pack

    Mike and Ike Root Beer Float Theatre Pack

    $3.99
  • Mike and Ike Cotton Candy Theatre Pack - 4.25oz

    Mike and Ike Cotton Candy Theatre Pack - 4.25oz

    $3.99
  • Zotz Fizz Power Candy Strings-Cherry-Apple-Watermelon

    Zotz - Fizz Power Candy Strings - Cherry-Apple-Watermelon

    $0.89
  • Bit-O-Honey Candy Bars - 1.7 oz.

    Bit-O-Honey Candy Bars - 1.7 oz.

    $2.00
  • Rocky Road Candy Bar | Annabelle Candy

    Rocky Road Bar

    $2.49
  • Boyer Mallo Cup - 1.5oz mallow marshmallow cups original candy company canada usa retro old fashioned nostalgic chocolate

    Boyer Mallo Cup - 1.5oz

    $3.89
  • Zagnut Bar

    Zagnut Bar

    $3.89
  • Mike and Ike Mega Mix Sour Candy - 4.255oz

    Mike and Ike Mega Mix Theatre Pack - 4.25oz

    $3.99
  • M&ms White Strawberry Shortcake - Chocolate

    Valentines M&M's White Strawberry Shortcake

    $10.00
  • 🏷️ Sweet Deal
    David Original Sunflower Seeds-1.75 oz. - Sunflower Seeds - American Snacks

    DAVID Original Sunflower Seeds - 1.75 oz *BB Jan 23 2026*

    Sale$2.29 $1.14
  • Oreo Red Velvet

    Oreo Red Velvet

    $14.99
  • Swizzels Love Hearts Dip (UK) - 23g

    Swizzels Love Hearts Dip (UK) - 23g

    $1.99
  • Reese's White Peanut Butter Cups KING SIZE - 2.8oz

    Reese's White KING SIZE Peanut Butter Cups - 2.8oz

    $4.49
  • Slo Poke Caramel Candy 1.5oz

    Slo Poke Caramel Candy

    $2.99
  • M&M's Crispy 38g

    M&M's Crispy - 1.35oz

    $2.69
  • Oreo Mint Chip - 303g

    Oreo Mint Chip - 303g

    $17.99
  • Astro Pop - Original

    Astro Pop - Original Lollipop 1oz

    $4.49
  • White Gumballs SweetWorks 1kg - Bulk Candy Buffet Colour_White Gum gumball

    Gumballs White

    $21.99
  • Black Gumballs SweetWorks 1kg - Black Bulk Candy Buffet Colour_Black Gum

    Gumballs Black

    $21.99
  • Hot Tamales Bulk Candy

    Hot Tamales Bulk Candy - 5lb

    $38.99
  • Allan Hot Lips Bulk Candy The Allan Candy Company 2.5kg - 1930s Allan Bulk Candy Allan Candy Bulk Canadian Nutrition Facts - Ingredients

    Allan Hot Lips Bulk Candy - 2.5 kg

    $32.99