$2.49
Whatchamacallit Bar
Hershey's
Whatchamacallit American Candy Bars I'll have one of those.... hm... Whatchamacallits? This Peanut-Flavoured Crisp topped with a layer of caramel a...
View full details
$2.49
Kosher
$2.09
100 Grand Bar
Ferrero
100 Grand American Chocolate Bars Retro Candy from the 1960's 100 Grand Bar provides a richer, more rewarding snack experience because of its crunc...
View full details
$2.09
Sold out
$8.00
1 LB Assorted Salt Water Taffy
Taffy Town
Assorted Salt Water Taffy Old Fashioned & Nostalgic Candy Salt Water Taffy is delicious. When you purchase this item you'll get a 1 pound bag o...
View full details
$8.00
Sold out
$3.49
Buncha Crunch - Theatre Pack
Nestlé
Old Fashioned Candy from the 1930s "Fun To Munch" A whole "buncha" fun to eat and share during any movie! The Buncha Crunch Theater Box will h...
View full details
$3.49
$2.79
Nik L Nip Wax Bottle Candy-4 Pack
Tootsie Roll Industires
Nik-L-Nip Mini Drinks Wax Bottles 4-Pack “Bite 'Em, Drink 'Em, Chew 'Em” Nik-L-Nips are known by Old School Candy Lovers as Wax Bottles. When they ...
View full details
$2.79
$39.99
Hershey's Kisses
Hershey's
Hershey's Milk Chocolate Kisses Bulk Candy Hershey's Kisses are an old fashioned candy that has been around since 1907! Made from the most deliciou...
View full details
$39.99
$28.99
Atomic Fireball
Ferrara Candy Co.
Atomic Fireball Hot Cinnamon Jawbreakers Candy Remember those Sweet and Hot Memories. Atomic Fireball... Even the name is hot, hot, hot! It's got t...
View full details
$28.99
$24.99
Laffy Taffy Assorted Flavours Tub-145 CT
Nestle Candy Shop
Laffy Taffy will make you laugh Enjoy the delicious chewy sweetness of the original Laffy Taffy in their mini forms! Each tub contains 145 pieces o...
View full details
$24.99
$29.99
Dubble Bubble Bubblegum Assorted 420+ Pieces
Tootsie Roll Industires
Dubble Bubble Bubblegum Assorted Flavours America's Original Bubblegum! Dubble Bubble Bubblegum means yummy summertime fun. We've been blowing this...
View full details
$29.99
$3.99
M&M's Coffee Nut Share Size
Mars
M&M's Coffee Nut Chocolate Candies Winning Flavour They did the poll and all the Sweeties in Candy Land chose M&M's Coffee Nut Chocolate Ca...
View full details
$3.99
$69.99
Rock Candy Sticks-Assorted
Espeez
Assorted Flavours Rock Candy Sticks An Old Fashioned Candy for your Candy Buffet Espeez Assorted Rock Candy Sticks are made with the highest qual...
View full details
$69.99
$2.00
3 Musketeers Bar
Mars Inc.
3 Musketeers American Chocolate Bars Retro Candy from Mars... This Old Fashioned Candy will bring Sweet Memories! 3 Musketeers Bars are American ch...
View full details
$2.00
$31.00
Salt Water Taffy - Assorted
Taffy Town
Taffy Town Assorted Flavoured Salt Water Taffy Old Fashioned Candy for over 100 years! Assorted flavoured Salt Water Taffy is a fantastic retro add...
View full details
$31.00
$24.00
Dubble Bubble with Comics Tub-240 Pieces
Concord Confections Ltd
Dubble Bubble Bubblegum with Comics Since 1928 This tub is not only filled with 240 pieces of the original flavour Dubble Bubble Bubblegum but eac...
View full details
$24.00