Home » Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Take a Stroll Down Memory Lane with all the Old Fashioned & Retro Candy you remember...and some you forgot!

Filter products
Clear all

1833 Products

  • Hubba Bubba Mega Long Fancy Fruit UK

    Hubba Bubba Mega Long Fancy Fruit UK - 56g

    $7.49
  • Hubba Bubba Mega Long Cola 56g

    Hubba Bubba Mega Long Cola Gum - 56g

    $7.49
  • Haribo Ghostly Gummies Haribo 0.14kg - 1920s Era_1920s gummies gummy halloween

    Halloween Haribo Ghostly Gummies

    $3.50
  • Haribo Minions Gummy Candy Haribo 0.14kg - 1920s Era_1920s gummies gummy Haribo

    Haribo Minions Gummy Candy

    $4.99
  • Haribo Sour Vampire Bats - 4oz

    Haribo Sour Vampire Bats - 4oz

    $3.99
  • Gerrit's Broadway on Wheels Strawberry Licorice Wheels

    Gerrit's Broadway on Wheels Strawberry Licorice Wheels - 5.29oz

    $4.49
  • Gerrit's Broadway on Wheels Black Licorice Wheels - 5.29oz

    Gerrit's Broadway on Wheels Black Licorice Wheels - 5.29oz

    $4.49
  • Old Fashioned Cherry Creme Drops - Retro Candy

    Old Fashioned Cherry Creme Drops

    $3.50
  • Old Fashioned Vanilla Creme Drops - Retro Candy

    Old Fashioned Vanilla Creme Drops

    $3.50
  • Charms Assorted Squares Candy

    Charms Assorted Squares Candy

    $3.99
  • Valomilk Candy Cups - American Candy

    Valomilk Candy Cups - 2oz

    $4.99
  • ✨Candyologist Pick✨
    Toxic Waste Slime Licker 2.0 - 2oz

    Toxic Waste Slime Licker 2.0 - 2oz

    $4.99
  • Milka Oreo Mint Chocolate Candy Bar Mondelez 50g - 2000s American Bar Chocolate Era_2000s

    Milka Oreo Mint Chocolate Candy Bar

    $3.50
  • Pez Super Mario Gift Set - Pez Candy Dispensers

    PEZ Super Mario Gift Set

    $25.00
  • Haribo Smurfs Sour! Gummy Candy - 4oz.

    Haribo Smurfs Sour! Gummy Candy - 4oz.

    $3.99
  • Pop Rocks Xtreme Sour Berry Blast/ Savage Sour Apple - .24oz.

    Pop Rocks Xtreme Sour Berry Blast/ Savage Sour Apple - .24oz.

    $1.49
  • Star Wars PEZ Collectors Tin Pez 100g - 2000s Christmas Gift Ideas Era_2000s new item Novelty

    PEZ Millenium Falcon Collectors Tin

    $29.99
  • Oreo Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies UK

    Oreo Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies- UK

    $5.99
  • Kool-Aid Strawberry Lemonade Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Strawberry Lemonade Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Kool-Aid Lemon-Lime Drink Mix Packet

    Kool-Aid Lemon-Lime Drink Mix Packet

    $1.29
  • Moon Pie Double Decker Chocolate Marshmallow Sandwich 78g

    Moon Pie Double Decker Chocolate Marshmallow Sandwich - 78g

    $1.79
  • Werther's Original Caramel Hard Candies No Sugar Added - 70g

    Werther's Original Caramel Hard Candies No Sugar Added - 70g

    $5.49
  • Werthers Original Chocolate Toffee - German Candy

    Werther's Original Chocolate Toffee - 125g

    $4.99
  • Werther's Original Soft Eclairs Caramels - Chocolate 116g

    Werther's Original Soft Eclairs Chocolate Caramel - 116g

    $4.99