Home » Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Shop By Decade - Pre 1920s - 2000s Candy

Take a Stroll Down Memory Lane with all the Old Fashioned & Retro Candy you remember...and some you forgot!

Filter products
Clear all

1834 Products

  • Krabby Patties Original 5.7oz

    Halloween Krabby Patties Original Bag - 5.7oz

    $5.69
  • Krabby Patties Mix Up Bag 45ct -14.2oz

    Halloween Krabby Patties Mix Up Bag 45ct -14.2oz

    $13.99
  • Toxic Waste Halloween Bank Assorted with Stickers - 3oz

    Halloween Toxic Waste Halloween Bank Assorted with Stickers - 3oz

    $7.99
  • ✨Candyologist Pick✨
    Sour Power Cotton Candy Straws 1.75oz

    Sour Power Cotton Candy Straws - 1.75oz

    $3.29
  • Stauffer's Pumpkin Pie Snaps - 14oz

    Halloween Stauffer's Pumpkin Pie Snaps - 14oz

    $4.49
  • Stauffer's Apple Pie Snaps - 14oz

    Halloween Stauffer's Apple Pie Snaps - 14oz

    $4.49
  • Stauffer's Halloween Shortbread Cookies - 12oz

    Halloween Stauffer's Halloween Shortbread Cookies - 12oz

    $4.49
  • Bounty UK Spread - 200g

    Bounty UK Spread - 200g

    $9.99
  • Milky Way UK Spread - Milky Way - Milky Way Spread - Milky Way Chocolate Bar - Chocolate Spread

    Milky Way UK Spread - 200g

    $9.99
  • Nestle Halloween Asorted Candy Bars

    Halloween Nestle Halloween Asorted Candy Bars - 24.8oz

    $21.99
  • Halloween 100 Grand Bar Fun Size 10oz

    100 Grand Fun Size Bars - 10oz

    $14.99
  • Butterfinger Fun Size Jumbo - 19.8oz

    Halloween Butterfinger Fun Size Jumbo Bag - 19.8oz

    $15.99
  • Baby Ruth Bar Fun Size Jumbo - 19.8oz

    Halloween Baby Ruth Bar Fun Size Jumbo Bag - 19.8oz

    $15.99
  • Butterfinger Fun Size - 10.2oz

    Butterfinger Fun Size Bars - 10.2oz

    $14.99
  • Baby Ruth Fun Size Bars - 10.2oz

    Baby Ruth Fun Size Bars - 10.2oz

    $14.99
  • Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Franken-Cup Green Creme - 9.6oz

    Halloween Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Franken-Cup Green Creme - 9.6oz

    $10.99
  • Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Glow in the Dark Snack Size - 9.35oz

    Halloween Reese's Peanut Butter Cups Glow in the Dark Snack Size - 9.35oz

    $10.99
  • Payday Snack Size - 11.6oz

    Halloween Payday Snack Size - 11.6oz

    $10.99
  • Haribo S'Witches' Brew - 10oz

    Halloween Haribo S'Witches' Brew - 10oz

    $5.99
  • Oreo Spooky Heads - 1.09oz

    Halloween Oreo Spooky Heads - 1.09oz

    $2.49
  • Gummy Candy Body Parts - 50ct - Gummy Candy - Gummies - Gummy - Gummy Candy Body Parts - Halloween Candy - Halloween Gummies - Gummy Body Parts - Candy Body Parts

    Gummy Candy Body Parts - 50ct

    $15.99
  • Skittles Zombie Share Size - 3.6oz

    Halloween Skittles Zombie Share Size - 3.6oz

    $3.99
  • Skittles Mash Ups Tropical+Wild Berry Candies

    Skittles Mash Ups Tropical+Wild Berry Candies - 7.2oz

    $6.49
  • Hubba Bubba Mega Long Triple Mix - Hubba Bubba - Bubblegum - Bubble Gum

    Hubba Bubba Mega Long Triple Mix - 56g

    $7.49